Study Shows How Restored Wetlands Rarely Equal Condition of Original Wetlands

By Robert Sanders – UC Berkeley Blog – January 24, 2012
Wetland restoration is a billion-dollar-a-year industry in the United States that aims to create ecosystems similar to those that disappeared over the past century. But a new analysis of restoration projects shows that restored wetlands seldom reach the quality of a natural wetland. http://newscenter.berkeley.edu/2012/01/24/study-shows-restored-wetlands-rarely-equal-condition-of-original-wetlands/

Posted in wetlands | Leave a comment

Not All Wetlands Are Created Equal

By Rachel Nuwer – New York Times Blog – January 24, 2012
To many, it’s a familiar scenario: a strip mall suddenly pops up in what was once a desolate quagmire or boggy boondock. But people are coming to realize that these seemingly wasted plots where land meets water provide a valuable ecological service. In addition to nurturing biodiversity, wetlands purify water, produce fish, store carbon dioxide that would otherwise contribute to global warming, and protect shorelines from floods, storm surges and erosion.
http://green.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/01/24/not-all-wetlands-are-created-equal/

Posted in wetlands | Leave a comment

Wetland mitigation along with wetland restoration is a relatively recent concept, recognized on a national level after the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) signed the Mitigation Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) in 1990. http://water.epa.gov/lawsregs/guidance/wetlands/mitigate.cfm

The mitigation MOA was a formal agreement between EPA and the Corps; it formalized the process of avoiding, minimizing and mitigating for aquatic alteration.  It contains the policy and procedures to be used in determining the type and level of mitigation necessary to demonstrate compliance with the Section 404(b)(1) Guidelines in carrying out the Section 404 dredge and fill permitting requirements. It provided a uniform process designed in the increasing mitigation activities occurring throughout the country.

As mitigation became a standard part of the Section 404 permitting program, questions were raised about whether and how wetlands could be replaced successfully on the landscape.  Early evaluations identified many problems with onsite permittee-responsible mitigation leading to the identification of third party opportunities: mitigation banking and in-lieu fee.

A 2001 National Academy of Sciences report:   Compensating For Wetland Losses Under The Clean Water Act http://www.nap.edu/openbook.php?isbn=0309074320 provided a benchmark on progress implementing the mitigation MOA in the field.  The report was a comprehensive analysis of the effectiveness of compensatory mitigation under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act. It identified a number of shortcomings in current policy and provided specific recommendations for federal agencies and states on how to proceed with effective ecological replacement of wetland functions lost to authorized development activities.

The report received a lot of attention and on December 24, 2002, six federal agencies signed the National Mitigation Action Plan. http://water.epa.gov/lawsregs/guidance/wetlands/upload/2003_07_10_wetlands
_map1226withsign.pdf
.  The plan laid out a strategy for the federal agencies to work with states and tribes to address areas of ambiguity and increase accountability for wetland mitigation.

The 2008 mitigation rule codified many issues resolved by various committees, workgroups and forums that grew out of the mitigation action plan.  It adopted and applied ‘lessons learned’ from the efforts of wetland regulators, scientists, consultants and others working in the field.  Evaluating this progress is evident when looking at some of the many studies of mitigation success over the last 10 years.

A report from Missouri evaluating mitigation sites established prior to 2004 found that while applicants made good efforts to complete mitigation, it was difficult to evaluate success because the measures included in the permits were too general to quantify.

Another report reviewing mitigation banks in Florida evaluating sites established in 2006 and earlier determined that while sites generally met success criteria, they did not meet the highest scores, which were the basis for the credits sold.

A more recent report from North Carolina evaluating sites from 2007-2009 determined that 74% of the wetlands and 75% of the stream mitigation sites met their design requirements.  This was up from 20%-40% in studies conducted in the mid-90s.

What can we conclude?  We know a lot more due to an enormous amount of work undertaken by federal agencies, states, scientists, consultants and many others. We’re a lot better than we were in the beginning.  But are these studies representative of the rest of the country?  The only way to determine that would be to conduct a national assessment of mitigation success.

The Environmental Law Institute has taken on that challenge by convening a panel of wetland scientists to develop a study designed to assess the regulatory and ecological outcomes of the three compensatory mitigation mechanisms. These are mitigation banking, in-lieu fee mitigation and permittee-responsible mitigation. The study has been organized in a manner that will enable comparisons of the three mechanisms nationwide. The next step will be to identify the funding to conduct such a study, which is critical to continuing to build on progress made over the past 20 years.  For a list of studies, training and other materials on mitigation visit: http://www.eli.org/Program_Areas/WMB/index.cfm

For many of the documents described above as well as other information visit the U.S. Environmental Mitigation webpage: http://water.epa.gov/lawsregs/guidance/wetlands/wetlandsmitigation_index.cfm

Posted in dredge and fill, environmental law, mitigation, permitting | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

American Carbon Registry Initiates Approval of World’s First Carbon Offset Methodology for Deltaic Wetland Restoration

January 18, 2012
American Carbon Registry (ACR), a nonprofit enterprise of Winrock International, announces an open public comment period for a first-of-its-kind carbon offset methodology that will both quantify how wetland restoration work can combat climate change and provide a way to help pay for rebuilding the Gulf of Mexico’s disappearing coastal wetland. The methodology, Restoration of Degraded Deltaic Wetlands of the Mississippi Delta, was funded by Entergy Corporation and developed by Dr. Sarah K. Mack of New Orleans-based Tierra Resources LLC, with contributions from Dr. Robert R. Lane, Dr. John W. Day and Tiffany M. Potter. For full blog post, go to:
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/american-carbon-registry-initiates-approval-of-worlds-first-carbon-offset-methodology-for-deltaic-wetland-restoration-2012-01-18

Posted in wetland restoration, wetlands | Leave a comment

Reactive Nitrogen

By Sam/Virginia Tech blog – November 2011
https://blogs.lt.vt.edu/sday178/2011/11/22/reactive-nitrogen/

New report reviews US nitrogen pollution impacts and solutions

By Woods Hole Research Center – January 17, 2012
http://www.sciencecodex.com/read/new_report_reviews_us_nitrogen_
pollution_impacts_and_solutions-84465

Posted in wetlands | Leave a comment

In November 2011, the International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) released a report that confirmed a link between extreme weather-related disasters like hurricanes, floods, tsunamis and other storms, to climate change. This was the first time that the IPCC emphasized this link in an official report based on the consensus of over 200 scientists. One of the lead authors of the report is also a director at the Red Cross/Red Crescent Climate Centre.  The Red Cross confirmed that the findings of the IPCC reflect what the Red Cross has observed:

‘The Red Cross warned that disaster agencies were already dealing with the effects of climate change in vulnerable countries across the world. “The findings of this report certainly tally with what the Red Cross Movement is seeing, which is a rise in the number of weather-related emergencies around the world,” said Maarten van Aalst, director of the Red  Cross / Red Crescent Climate Centre and coordinating lead author of the IPCC report. “We are  committed to responding to disasters whenever and wherever they happen, but we have to  recognize that if the number of disasters continues to increase, the current model we have for responding to them is simply impossible to sustain.”’ – from The Guardian, Nov. 17, 2011 http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/nov/17/ipcc-climate-change-extreme-weather

The Red Cross/Red Crescent Climate Centre published a related report for policy-makers in light of this new information about extreme weather-related disasters and preparing for climate change. For the Summary for Policy Makers of the new Special Report on Extremes (Nov. 2011), visit: http://www.climatecentre.org/site/news/329/summary-for-policy-makers-of-the-new-special-report-on-extremes-srex

Strange Wetlands sought the first-hand perspective of Allen Crabtree, a volunteer for the Public Affairs division of the American Red Cross. Mr. Crabtree has volunteered with the Red Cross since Katrina. He has identified many human interest stories and interviewed those affected by floods, hurricanes, tornadoes and other extreme-weather disasters. In the past year, the Red Cross deployed Mr. Crabtree to cover the stories of Hurricane Irene and related flooding events in Vermont and the Mississippi River floods, and the tornadoes in South Carolina.

Mr. Crabtree arrives on the scene immediately after a hurricane, tornado, flood or forest fire has hit. Often he is deployed “pre-landfall,” before a hurricane has come ashore. It’s his job to get the word out to people –let them know where the Red Cross shelters and other services are located, to help prepare people for a disaster and to contact the media. He’s been known to set his laptop up and report via Skype with a hurricane raging around him. The Red Cross makes use of social media, too, to spread the news—over Facebook, Twitter and Youtube. However, social media can be a way for rumors to spread, for example, when the Mississippi River floods occurred, there was a false rumor posted on Twitter about the Red Cross offering a particular service; but these social media outlets are closely monitored, and rumors are quickly squashed.

Extreme weather-related disasters are expensive and the Red Cross uses footage of the storms, the damage and the people in shelters, to raise funds for their efforts. But Mr. Crabtree’s first love—writing stories—is what drives him to reach out to people. Thinking back on the Mississippi River floods, Mr. Crabtree said, “The sad thing about floods is that they are a slow-moving disaster. When do you evacuate? Afterwards, it makes a slow retreat as the water levels return to normal.” Unlike a tornado with its fast path of destruction, a flood, or even a hurricane, can continue to damage communities and wreak havoc long after the onset of the storm. Mr. Crabtree has written about some of the “success stories” among the Red Cross shelters during the Mississippi River floods and other storms this year, stories, he says, about “people picking themselves up in the face of a lot of impediments. They are a shining example of the resilience of people.” Read Allen Crabtree’s stories here on the Red Cross website via the links below the photo.

Red Cross Reaches Out to Aid Vermont Flood Family (Vermont flood, September 2011)

Red Cross Shelters Residents of Transvale Acres in Flooded Conway, NH (2011)

“What do I do after the flood?” (North Dakota, 2011)

Red Cross is here for the Long Haul (Mississippi River floods, 2011)

Disaster Can Change Someone’s Life in Seconds (North Carolina tornado, 2011)

Video, News Channel 8: Interview with Allen Crabtree on the Joplin tornado (June 2011)

Strong Waters, Stronger Friendships (Missouri floods, 2008)

Posted in Communication, climate change, floods/floodplains, natural hazards | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Fight looms over SC Supreme Court wetlands ruling

CarolinaLive.com – January 8, 2012
South Carolina developers and environmentalists are gearing for a fight over wetlands and building when lawmakers open their news legislative session this week. The (Columbia) State reports the question is whether South Carolina should establish a statewide permitting program for isolated wetlands, or pass a law limiting the impact of a state Supreme Court ruling. http://www.carolinalive.com/news/story.aspx?id=705024#.Tw2nnaVrM-l

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Wetlands and Farms: One Example at Panghorn Bog

Washington Landscpae–January 10, 2012
The Washington State Court of Appeals recently ruled in favor of Whatcom County regarding the clearing of a wetland on a farm in the northern part of the county. The farm had been a dairy farm and had been acquired by a berry farm. A portion of the farm consisted of a forested wetland and the new berry farm cleared a 10 acre chunk of the forest for a new blue berry field. The clearing was done without a permit – a violation of the County Critical Areas Ordinance. The county required the wetland impacts be repaired. The farm abandoned the field, but apparently paused at the restoration that was required. The farm appealed first to the County Hearing Examiner, then then the Council, then to the Superior Court and finally to the State Court of Appeals all of which upheld the County wetland enforcement. http://washingtonlandscape.blogspot.com/2012/01/wetlands-and-farms-one-example-at.html

Posted in wetlands | Leave a comment

Sea Stories: Coastal & Marine Conservation Lit

The hibernal issue of Sea Stories has been published, which includes four wetland poems by ASWM’s Leah Stetson that originally appeared on The Compleat Wetlander. Sea Stories is Blue Ocean Institute’s quarterly online journal of international ocean writing and art.  To read Leah’s wetland poetry and the rest of Sea Stories, go to: http://seastories.org/2011/12/leah-c-stetson/

Posted in wetlands | Leave a comment

Who’s Naughty and Who’s Nice: A Year After the Everglades Big Sugar Deal

By Tasha Eichenseher – National Geographic – December 23, 2011
Your celebration this season is, in part, brought to you by southern Florida, where almost 50 percent of the nation’s sugarcane crop comes from. Last year Florida gave us 12,230,000 tons of cane and 1,433,000 tons of crystallized bliss (refined sugar). Hawaii, Louisiana, and Texas made contributions too, but not on the same scale. http://newswatch.nationalgeographic.com/2011/12/23/sugar-plum-fairies-a-year-after-the-everglades-big-sugar-deal/

Posted in wetlands | Leave a comment